signal vs telegram
thilov last edited by thilov
@RandomUser You can use the UTTT to disable the backgroundsuspending. While Axolotl is open in the background, you will receive notifications.
Mic_ last edited by Mic_
Here is an interesting article about how in Signal is beeing invested: https://www.wired.com/story/signal-encrypted-messaging-features-mainstream/
Is there any possibility to connect Signal and Telegram somehow? Or what has to be done that that can be achieved? Does somebody know?
Telegram has something about 200 Millionen users worldwide - is after WA with more than 1 billion No 2. Together with Signal both could be really an alternative!
Flohack last edited by
@Mic_ I dont think this would ever happen, since they are fundamentially different systems, and Signal would probably refuse to weaken their security to allow interaction.
For example, in Telegram there are no encrypted groups at all whereas they are encrypted on the Signal side. How you gonna deal with formiung groups between Signal and Telegram users? Also, those systems are base don a central service, you cannot just forward messages between both backends without further troubles.
People have to make a choice, and there will never the only perfect messenger for all people on this planet. And I think thats OK.
i read a rumor that whats app might start in app ads.
if this happens i think more people will switch to signal and Telegram .
Ok, understand. A little bit disappointing.
"Signal would probably refuse to weaken their security to allow interaction"
Yes that would be my next idea. If Signal 'allows' having contacts without encryption - would than a connection between 2 persons from telegram to signal imaginable?
I mean it could also be that this hardcore encryption will not all the time be allowed...?
And of course I agree that everybody should choose them freely - but actually one actor you can only install until you agree that he reads out your contacts and what you do on the phone - here we are not on a normal market I would argue. Not normal markets normally results in not normal regulations - we are only missing until now.
Flohack last edited by Flohack
@Mic_ besides the encryption issue you also need to federate both services together. There is for example the problem, what if a person has both Telegram AND Signal accounts registered to their phone number? The servers currently would not know how to route this.
If a service is not built with federation in mind like XMPP or Matrix its really really next to impossible to get this done properly at a later stage. I remember with horror the things Microsoft did to couple MSN Messenger and Skype accounts. It was never working as expected.
Or even Skype for Business and their former Lync application: Messages got stuck, people were always offline etc. And that was inside the same company
Ok, thx for the explanation! I really didn't know how complex that is. And if MSN and Skype did not work ... I understand.
So if somebody wants to go the regulative way, it must be defined a protocoll or something which all messengers have to be able to handle (at least additionaly).
And probably that would never happen.
Would it be imaginable that Telegram or Signal have to add e.g. XMPP?
Ok I really have no idea what Telegram is doing different - but a protocoll just means nohing else than a predefined order of info inside a file - which should be at least possible.
I am also not sure if a connection between messengers will not bring more problems than it solves - but the market position of WA would be broken during a short time.
However, thx for the input.
PhoenixLandPirat last edited by
Here's some more context for signal with integration with other messengers.
EU 'recommends' Signal to EU-staff and proofs WA
Pulsar33 last edited by
Time for Signal is coming, due to WhatsApp agreement ultimatum !
I'm getting flagged as spam. I'm not sure how to post this ... I'll try it piecemeal.
I just happen to have put together a list of links on Telegram. I suggest we stay far away from their "roll your own" crypto. That's the first thing you'll learn in a crypto class.
Moxie (Signal protocol) and Matt Green (John's Hopkins/zcash) are crypto experts. The Grugg is a well known infosec researcher, but I don't know his background as well. Durov is owner of Telegram
Moxie's comment to Telegram/Durov:
Telegram crypto defeated (2013)
Moxie's comment on their new crypo
Lakotaubp last edited by
@diagon This is a really old thread and not totally sure why you posted the links here so removed them.
@lakotaubp - because I have researched the history of Telegram, of which this thread is about; and Telegram vs. Signal is still a relevant issue.
Could you please let me post these?
Please stop deleting these links.
Lakotaubp last edited by
@diagon It might be a discussion for Off Topic but not in a really old thread about the merits or not of Signal or Telegram in general. If you want to start a discussion on those issues then feel free to do so in OT as no doubt similar issues affect more than these platforms. Also be Careful with links to off forum sites