Pixel 3a XL experience

joshndroid · 8 Oct 2021, 03:03

@wsanford I cannot believe I literally have just been going through the same thing. Fresh ebay second hand 3XL... latest deb beta 0.9.1 and stuck at google screen. Thankfully I found this and the 0.8.8 version worked FIRST time. Definitely something wonky with install on the later versions. Thanks mate, one happy fellow enthusiast here (Even made an account just to post this)

wsanford · 9 Oct 2021, 20:28

@joshndroid Glad to be of any help. Things have been going much better than expected for me. I'm very impressed with the efforts to bring this to be. Last night I tried to swap the SIM card over to test drive it but the Verizon guy online couldn't get my SIM card free from my old phone, so Monday I'll have to go into the store. But, if that's the worst problem I have, I'll be happy with that. LOL

rik · 10 Oct 2021, 20:24

@wsanford said in Pixel 3a XL experience:

Last night I tried to swap the SIM card over to test drive it but the Verizon guy online couldn't get my SIM card free from my old phone, so Monday I'll have to go into the store

Unfortunately I don't think you are going to be able to get calls working on Verizon Their older network is CDMA and the newer one is VoLTE, both of which don't work as of this moment. Data should work (??) but calls and sms are probably of interest Sorry for this discouragement, could you consider a GSM-based SIM? For example, US Mobile (T-Mobile reseller) works well and is $12 / mo for unlimited calls, SMS, and 1GB data. But of course I understand if coverage may not be good for you. VoLTE work has been identified but it will be a while before it is usable.

wsanford · 11 Oct 2021, 00:13

@rik I appreciate the heads up. I'm not picky on the carrier at this point. I'll look into T-Mobile in my area. Thanks a bunch.

joshndroid · 12 Oct 2021, 09:27

@wsanford Im on the other side of the planet...

I've just been tinkering around as yet to get it to some sort of daily ready device.
It reminds me a lot of early android tinkering... a bit of fun to it

wsanford · 12 Oct 2021, 15:58

@joshndroid Hey it was good info though. I stopped by t-mobile yesterday and got a plan that is better than my Verizon one. It ran me 50 bucks a month but I have unlimited everything and no annual restrictions, even hot spot is working. Coverage for Eastern North Carolina seems to be great. Still no MMS but I can send and receive pictures on telegram, which my friends and I use. So, I'm daily driving, it connects to my truck just fine for calls and using futify to play music over the stereo. All is good.

wsanford · 12 Oct 2021, 16:03

@joshndroid sorry for any confusion, I was responding to @rik , Oh yes, it is a lot of fun tinkering.

thousandtopics · 10 Dec 2021, 22:25

@wsanford with the amount that you pay, I feel blessed that I pay less ($7.22). It might be that is not a plan. It's like a . . refill? I just pay for 28 days of service when I can. I'm not sticked to a plan.

rik · 13 Oct 2021, 00:32

@wsanford said in Pixel 3a XL experience:

Still no MMS but I can send and receive pictures on telegram, which my friends and I use

I am sure we can get MMS to work with "fiddling" with your APN settings. Make sure you have DIFFERENT APN entries for "Data" and "MMS" entries. If they are the same APN for 2 entries then UT gets confused. Also, MMS group messages don't work, but photos do. Finally, you need to have wifi disabled to receive / send MMS (yet another shortcoming for now, hopefully we can work this out in the future to always prefer cellular data for MMS so it works with wifi on or off).

If you are stuck / confused on APN settings, please post what they currently are and we can get it sorted.

wsanford · 13 Oct 2021, 21:30

@rik Thank you for all the help! I've been a Linux Admin for a number of years now but I'm new to learning phones and all the information is very much appreciated, I'm sure it will be of help to others as well.Downsizing pic's didn't work well so here are a couple links to the settings.
T-Mobile MMS Internet/web

wsanford · 13 Oct 2021, 21:54

@thousandtopics Yeah, I wish I could have gotten out cheaper but I need hot spot and unlimited data for work and kids for On-Call work and kids doing remote schooling sometimes. It's working out very well.

rik · 13 Oct 2021, 23:19

@wsanford here are the T-Mobile APN settings that were reported to the UBPorts "North America Carrier Issues" group that seem to work:

Used For: MMS
Name: T-Mobile MMS
APN: pwg
MMSC: http://pwg.mmsmvno.com/mms/wapenc
<Proxy, Proxy Port, User Name, Password ALL BLANK>

NOTE: the above APN and MMSC are identical to the US Mobile settings (T-Mobile re-seller)

Used For: Internet
Name: T-Mobile Internet
APN: epc.tmobile.com
<User Name and Password BLANK>

So, can you try those and then possibly reboot to see if it works? There were some bugs around changing settings "not sticking" so let us know if that is a problem for you. Again, to test MMS you need wifi OFF, cellular data ON. Good Luck!

wsanford · 14 Oct 2021, 00:05

@rik Success!!! Thank you so much. It was odd though. It didn't work at first, so I drove into town and tried where I knew I would have the best signal, and still nothing. I came home and deleted the failed attempts and then tried again and it sent and received pictures just fine.

The settings are holding just fine after reboots.

rik · 14 Oct 2021, 01:13

@wsanford great news! There is a bug in there that prevents using the "internet and mms" option for a single APN setting. But good to hear you have it working even though a bit kludgy

Looking ahead, I would like to dig into making MMS work while on wifi (by effectively "forcing" cellular data for all MMS activities regardless of if wifi is on or off), then look at group mms (now the messages are actually received to your phone but no app knows what to do with them, so that is why no error message even is created, they just are not handled), etc.

Getting "full features of MMS" working well would be a big win for the North America market I suspect.

thousandtopics · 14 Oct 2021, 01:39

@wsanford your needs are way different than mine.

thousandtopics · 14 Oct 2021, 01:42

I have to say that this last update in the dev channel make the batery last for the most time since I got the phone. Whatever you have done. Don't change it, maintain it. This is highly appreciated.

thousandtopics · 14 Oct 2021, 01:46

@rik North América also Includes Canda and Mexico carriers?

wsanford · 14 Oct 2021, 15:43

@rik It's been working great all day today, and it's getting pictures just as fast as my S9 on Verizon. Thank you again! Turning off the WIFI is a bit of an inconvenience but at this point, I really don't mind it as I don't want it connecting to any insecure WIFI along the way, so I was already turning it off when leaving the house. If there is ever anything I can be of help with testing on a Pixel 3a XL, shoot it my way, I'd be happy to help.

rik · 14 Oct 2021, 23:46

@thousandtopics right now there are a few Canadians in the group as well, could be that Mexico has similar carrier issues, I am not sure.

For example, the "trickery" of US carriers detecting IMS capable handsets and then "behind the scenes" switching over incoming SMS to be delivered via IMS was a shared problem for some Canadian carriers as well. The "solution" of disabling IMS for the Pixel 3a "solved" incoming SMS issues for US and Canada, but not sure about Mexico.

It was trying to sort out "good old basic SMS" that initiated creating the "North American Carrier Issues" group because no one in Europe / Asia had any issues with incoming SMS. With carriers around the world moving at different times for VoLTE, etc., it seemed relevant to have a group dedicated to North America carrier issues.

thousandtopics · 16 Oct 2021, 15:51

@rik oh well I'm from México, so No problems with SMS at all. The only complain I might have is the audio quality in calls. . . It varies a lot. And I don't see the use of using MMS since family and friends use Telegram and different more complete chat services.