Fairphone 3 (FP3)

Luksus

Hi @Janez,
great that it works for you. And thanks for your help.

I can't confirm the telephony and camera bugs as you describe it. For the camera, you could try to change resolution and then switch back again.
Currently I am using another system-build (not GSI).
But I've also had some quirks here and there. Sometimes I could not stop the last phone-call, until I rebooted. Sometimes I was not able to send SMS, they also did not get displayed in history, but after a reboot, the recipient recieved all 3 SMS, I tried to sent.
I think some bugs could also be a result of the dev-build, we are using here.

I must admit that I am also not the one, who knows how to dig deeper into some issues.
I just look around and search for similar issues on similar phones and then try to apply the fix, which someone provided.

As I said above, I am currently testing another system-build, which I am using as daily driver currently. It gets build by the gitlab CI of the ubports repository.
Could you please try if it works for you, when just flash the system.img from here to your FP3?

download
boot to fastboot
then just execute: fastboot flash system system.img
reboot

What you could test here:

does it boot successfully?
does it still boot successfully, if you wipe the data partition (with twrp, or perhaps with fastboot)
- if not, does it boot again if you flash the boot.img from the gitlab CI link above
- if yes, that would be interesting

What I try to figure out here is:

If I understand it correctly, the GSI seems to boot the rootfs (ubports) from the data partition.
The CI build packaged the rootfs into the system-partition.

Normally you would either use boot.img together with system.img from the gitlab CI (option1) or use the halium-boot.img together with the GSI (option2, as you do currently).
The CI build also works, but has less working hardware yet. For example telephony only works when wifi is connected (strange thing).

I am not sure if you know how things work with a/b partitions on that/a phone.
I did flash option1 to the a-partitions and option2 to b-partitions.
Then I could switch with fastboot --set-active=a or fastboot --set-active=b between the options and compere them. The data partion is the same for both.
Then I just flashed the halium-boot.img also to option1 and looked how things work out and somehow it seems to work better than option2.
But what I not tested yet, if it perhaps just boots to the rootfs, which is placed on the data partition by the GSI.
I also would not understand why it would work better than the GSI then, because it would be the same, like booting option2.

Hm, I am not sure if it is clear, what I tried to describe...

007fred50

@Luksus i works for me the last post you added.

Janez

Hi @Luksus,
I tried to boot system.img and it worked on first try, no issues. In the meantime I executed sudo apt update && sudo apt upgrade so some package versions might have been different for me on previous build.
So far I was able to send and receive few SMS messages without need of reboot.

Here are some points:

after fastboot flash system system.img phone successfully booted.
post TWRP:
- after TWRP phone did not boot
- tried to flash system.img again, did not boot
- flashed boot.img and system.img and successfully booted

After newly flashed system wifi did not appear to be working. However after reboot everything seems working. I also so far did not apply switching between two options you suggested.
Also issues I have been describing in previous post seem to be solved, in the next days I will be using this build and will refer how system works.

Luksus

@Janez Thank's for testing.

If I undrestand it right, the combination of halium-boot.img and system.img did not work for you?

And as you are currently using the CI boot.img and system.img, does telephony and cellular data connection work for you?

oli.sax

@007fred50 said in Fairphone 3 (FP3):

Nice it works now ! thanks

Hello Fred! So you were able to downgrade your FP3+ to Android 9 then install UT GSI; and Ubuntu Touch is working on FP3+?

If that is the case it's nice, it means we can develop a unique image for both FP3 and FP3+

007fred50

@oli-sax Hello,

Yes android 9 and ubuntu touch works on fairphone 3 +

do you want to flash ubuntu touch or android 9?

you can download the files here (http://people8people.com/fairphone/)

download - fairphone3_ubports.zip
there are a text file follow that

Start (wipe data) with twrp. then follow 1, the file

Janez

@Luksus yes, you understand right.

halium-boot.img and CI system.img does not boot from fresh
CI boot.img and system.img boot successfully

So far I found strange combination which works for me:

SIM card in slot 1 works and phone recognizes it. However to make phone call I need to be connected to some WiFi with internet access
SIM card in slot 2 works with and without WiFi connection
Cellular data (2G/3G/4G) does not work for me for halium-boot.img as well as CI boot.img so here I suspect wrong setup of APN. My operator did not provide me too much useful informations. I will try to work it out in next days.

Luksus

@Janez said in Fairphone 3 (FP3):

SIM card in slot 1 works and phone recognizes it. However to make phone call I need to be connected to some WiFi with internet access

SIM card in slot 2 works with and without WiFi connection

Ok, it is the same behaviour for me. That's why I did not make this version very official, because I think that is a show-stopper for using it daily.

Cellular data (2G/3G/4G) does not work for me for halium-boot.img as well as CI boot.img so here I suspect wrong setup of APN. My operator did not provide me too much useful informations. I will try to work it out in next days.

With halium-boot it is working perfectly fine for me (ok, sometimes I have to switch cellular data on and off to make it work).
With CI boot.img, I got a data connection displayed next to the simcard, but it is not making it to the "global" data indicator in the top, which means: no data connection at all.

Other things, that need to be solved for the CI version is Vibration and Notifications in standby mode.

Janez

I had some time to play around with the phone. I did fresh install of halium-boot.img from your build and sideloaded ubports_gsi.zip

I found very annoying bug - System time is set to 1st January 1970 and does not matter if I have set auto or manual time set. After reboot the phone still counts since 1970.
I tried to fix that by running sudo mount -o rw,remount / and after that performing time change but without success. On next boot I have yet again year 1970.

I also tried to perform sudo apt update and sudo apt upgrade. Web browser seems to improve in performance but the time issue is still there. I also noticed the phone does not respect change of timezone and just sits with that picked on first boot during settings.

BTW, I noticed there is LineageOS build for FP3. Not sure if this could help but AFAIK SailfishOS build by default relies on Lineage so it might be helpful for UBports as well.

Luksus

@Janez thanks for testing.

Regarding the time-bug: I encountered that the phone needs an internet connection to set the time again, every time it is rebooted.

Regardig your sudo apt upgrade: does the vibration feedback still work, after the update? I read, that Erfan, who created the GSI, did create it's own patch for the "human feedback device"-things and that it would be overwritten on a system update.

In general, I will not try to fix things further for the GSI way, but for the other builds, in the Gitlab CI.
Recently, I managed to get mobile-data working. It is still needed to have any data-connection to be able to phone or send/recieve sms, but it is not further relying on the wifi-connection.
Lates Build is here.

flohack

The timekeeper needs to be fixed for reboots, its an Android service, and every port needs to address that. I can help with that maybe. Just ping me.

007fred50

Hello,

I can flash the Fairphone 3+ with the neweste OS from site page / (2020-12-01)

But someting does not working in FP3+:
Vibration = not working
Camera = not working
Sound = not working

Mabye the are FP3+ and not FP3.

Luksus

@007fred50 interesting.
Vibration is known for not working with this image.
But camera and audio does work for regular FP3. So it maybe has something to do with new camera and audio module of the FP3+.

Does they work with the GSI image?

Janez

Hello @Luksus,
Regarding sudo upgrade: vibration feedback works for me but is a bit laggy now. I guess it takes around 0,2 - 0,5s to vibrate after tap on icon but it can be caused by slow loading of an app. Keyboard vibrations work but I have them usually off. However while typing I can't change sound volume of the keyboard. It just sits at its level even though phone is in silent mode.

Regarding time-bug: while describing my issue I rebooted phone this morning. It took around an 1hr to set right time, I guess I need to be more patient next time.

In the mean time I noticed an error with missing _apt user (command apt could not get rid of permissions) so I tried to add it manually. For now error is gone but I have no idea if I did it right or if this user has to be in specific group.

As soon as the Gitlab CI build will be able to make calls and sms, will hop on it and try but for now phone calls are important to me and I do not always have access to internet connection.

007fred50

@Luksus Hej

i have installed GSI image V10 now, Fairphone 3 +

GSI:
Updates = Not Working
Vibration = Working
Camera = Not Working
Sound = Not Working
Turn Power Off = Working

GITLAB CI:
Updates = Working
Vibration = Not Working
Camera = Not Working
Sound = Not Working
Turn Power Off = Not Working (restarting)

So they have added new camera and sound modul

Luksus

@007fred50 did you also flash the halium-boot image again, for using it with the GSI?
I ask, because vibration should work here...

@007fred50 & @Janez Does the Notification LED work correctly in the GSI?`

Because it seems that it does for the GITLAB CI BUILT now.

007fred50

@Luksus Yes i flash the halium-boot image

I don't know there to trun the Notification LED on?

FP2andFP3-User

@Luksus
thanks for your support on FP3.
I'm testing both isos, but CI is working better and most of the stuff is running well.
SIM card is running
bluetooth is running
camera is working
sound is working
headset is working

I'm waiting for cellular data connection!
I could download you ISO 20 days ago and flash boot and system. Your last system build from yesterday I can't flash (fastboot flash system ...) . It stops always by 3/5 sending sparse 'system' and do nothing.

Do you know what is the Problem?

thanks

Luksus

@FP2andFP3-User Hi, and thanks for joining

I never encountered such an issue like you described.
Can you confirm that the archive is completely downloaded (~824MB)?
Perhaps, try to download it again.

The extracted size of the system.img, should be around 2.29GB.

Currently there is a new build running, which also should enable Notification LED.

FP2andFP3-User

@Luksus

I did download several times....

But okay i See the New iso running i will try it after work in the evening....