click on notification bubble
-
@gpatel-fr Yes, I think talking about this in a forum is healthy and helps me (maybe others too) understand what others are thinking because it may not in the end be something that is desired...
I guess my first intention in asking the initial question was to see if this is an expected behaviour or it was rather supposed to work and it doesn't anymore.
So I understand that it was never meant (yet) to work this way - to click on the bubble and open the app that the bubble reffers to.
Then, I guess, I tried to ask if this is something that would be desired.
Then, I guess again, in case that would be a good idea, it would be the question if that is something that can be done.
-
I agree with this. Swiping the notification makes it disappear into the list. Tapping the notification should just execute the notification handler, like tapping it from the notification list does.
-
Tapping the notification should just execute the notification handler
You mean "tapping the notification bubble"?
-
@mihael yes, tapping the floating one that appears when the notification appears. It doesn't make sense to me to have the tap dismiss the notification into the notification bar, when you can do that with a swipe.
-
Its definitely a Lomiri UI inconsistency, not an app issue. From apps perspective, there's no way to tweak this behavior. And there's no difference between an app using dbus or the http apis to send notifications, they end up flowing over the same path in your device.
-
From apps perspective, there's no way to tweak this behavior.
not sure what you are meaning by 'this behavior' and 'tweaking'.
What I understand is there would be no way to display a time out notification and detect if the user has pressed the notification before it closes by itself.
If this is what you mean, this example shows how it can be done..
Granted, don't know if this can work from an unconfined app. This caveat was not part of the discussion
-
So just speaking from the user point of view, not developer:
Right now, there is a notification bubble that the user can interact with by swiping it away and this notification bubble also has a time out - it disappears by itself.
Then, there is the notification in the notification list - this notification has a "load" - like info about what app to open and some other info that is passed to the app. The user can interact with this notification by tapping on it - then the UI opens that specific app and passes that specific info to the app.
My question is: can't the "load" be included in the notification bubble as well? And then the UI adds the possibility for the user to interact with the bubble by tapping on it.
-
@mihael this is the intended behavior.
No click on notification bubbles, please.
I have disabled notification bubbles long time ago, as they turn on the screen and that's annoying.
Notifications should show in the notifications indicator. All of them in one place. -
@CiberSheep That could actually work as a workaround solution: to disable bubbles and enable notifications sound: this way I am notified that there is a new message / email but I don't have to wait for the bubble to disappear before I scroll down the notifications list and click on the notification. However, this introduces an extra step: to turn on the screen by pressing the power button.
What I was looking for is a simple, direct, straight forward way of being notified and then opening that specific app.
I also have to explain a detail about my context: I don't have a passcode or fingerprint reader enabled, so I don't have these extra steps of unlocking the phone.
-
@gpatel-fr I'm talking about the title, that an app has no API to set an action when clicking on the notification bubble.
I think your example shows that, as it is not using the official lomiri api for this. So it doesn't work with an http post to the push server for example.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login