Format SD card?
-
The Ubuntu-VollaPhone offers (from the beginning) an app "Externe Speichermedien" ("External storage media"),
which shows an entry for an inserted SD card, but the button "Formatieren" ("Format") is greyed out.
Is it really true that Ubuntu Touch expects a FAT32 (vfat) formatted card?
SD Extended Capacity cards (>32GB) usually are preformatted with exFAT and for a Linux system probably
a filesystem like e.g. ext4 is much better suited. Most user won't remove and insert the card very often.
Since I don't use any Windows or Mac systems, I removed the card, repartioned and reformated it with
ext4 and changed the fstab to mount it, but...What is default mount point for the SD card?
Why is the "external storage media" app not working?
I expect the app to reformat the card with a file system of my choice (e.g. ext4)...
Any clues?Thanks,
Martin -
@martin
External storage media is on all phone, i have it on my MX4 but don't have any SD slot.
It is used for SD card, but also for USB external devices.There is a bug on Volla Phone, i don't know if it's related to yours : https://github.com/HelloVolla/ubuntu-touch-beta-tests/issues/97
I also don't know if it's resolved with OTA-17.
-
@keneda
Thank you for the fast response and the hint. I was not aware of this "issue".
Hopefully this is fixed and also there will be improvements for the file system support
in the (near) future.In the meantime I reformatted the SDXC with a primary FAT32 (32GB) and ext4 partition (rest)
and at least the FAT32 was recognized.
But I also did an upgrade to OTA-17 and now the
Music and Camera app don't seem to work any more. (only hourglass-like animation shown)
(A Logviewer app showed me for "v2.9.22 music":
Loading module: 'libubuntu_application_api_touch_mirclient.so.3.0.0'
library "libpq_cust.so" not found' )
Not sure if the upgrade was the reason (the problem still exists without the sdcard inserted),
but this problem will get now a higher priority... -
@martin Ut only works on Fat32, Android can use Fat32 and Xfat. If you want to use a multipurpose micro SD, on the Pc make a partition for Ut with Fat 32 files, then create another partition without files (it doesn't contain anything) of about 100Mb, then you can create another partition in ext4 to use with Linux,
The partition (WITHOUT FILES) is so that the UT or Android operating system doesn't see the ext4 partition, in Android it won't let you use the card, in Ut it usually tells you to format the card, you should never do that.I hope this helps you a little,
regards... -
@josele13
With my 2 primary partitions - a vfat/FAT32 and an ext4 one -
UT tells me that it found a partion to include (the FAT32, which is mounted afterwards)
and another one, which could not be added (the ext4, which probably has to be mounted manually...).
So UT did not "ask" about formatting a SD card (yet).
Why is it necessary that UT does not "see" the ext4 partition?
And why should a UT user care about Android? (I don't!)
But I'm still disappointed that UT is limited to an "outdated" file system and I don't
really understand why this is the case - notably for a Linux system like UT.
Portability should not play a big role, since most users don't remove the SD card often.
Hopefully the UT file systems support will get better one day... -
It's better that Ut doesn't see it so it doesn't ask you to format the sd, if you do that you lose everything, it's not just for android, you also want to use the sd in a video or photo camera,
You never know where you can use it.Regards...
