UI / UX discussion



  • Sorry, I had to improve my last sentence. Hopefully, it's better understandable now.

    Sure, "home" stands for whatever will get used or configured in the future.

    As stated above the current "long-drag from left" gesture to get "home" is slow and is not equally good for both hands. It even unnecessarily often needs a movement of the complete hand on tablets, not easily done by only moving a finger that is holding the device. Please re-read above posts and think about the different mentioned aspects brought to the discussion that can be improved together, by optimizing the edge gesture assignments. To use your own words, put yourself in the shoes to compare the things like symmetry and the ease of explaining the usage.

    What do you think is so relevant about it --for optimizing edge gesture assignments-- to point out that touch gestures are useless without touchscreens, and that trackpad gestures can't be the same? Please elaborate if important.



  • @hummlbach said in UI / UX discussion:

    by letter sounds good. Then it would be fine for me and also an improvement compared to the app scope now in my opinion. Here is an example for what I meant posted by @PhoenixLandPirat in https://github.com/ubports/ubuntu-touch/issues/838:

    TBH I like almost everything that how is now Unity8.
    My usage (I'm righthanded)
    To launch apps: 100%of times I launch favourites apps from launcher.
    Apps that i don't usually use i launch it from scope (obviously xD).
    To change apps: Usually use the long gesture to select to the window I want to. I don't use often the back to previous window for now. Maybe i would use more often the short feature if there would be more apps that uses multiple windows like dekko2.
    I like the idea of the drawer and the idea to change apps scope to drawer since we can't mantain scopes. I'll miss scopes but @dobey have a point in the explanation to remove them :(

    The only thing I would change (not sure if the problem persist) is that in desktop mode the right edge is very sensitive with a mouse and that the invocation of multitasking with right edge with mouse was very statick in my opinion compared to gesture animations.

    Sorry for my English, I hope you can understand the message



  • I think it's not that easy to measure or calculate the improvements in snappiness and ease of use, compared to a practical test.

    So here it is:

    The only comparable action at the moment is the right edge "flip-to-latest-app". One could try out this flipping for a while, and then imagine you could flip apps left and right, and flip "home" in and out from the upper edge, with exactly the same speed!


  • Infrastructure

    Just 2 cents, I think that making the corners of any window that much rounded reminds me of Apple design. The proportion of the circled making up the rounded corner should be more like on the Suru icons. Its somewhat inconsistent right now with the rest of the UT design.



  • @flohack I'd say there's no good reason to make the screenshots have curved corners, as that's not how the windows are actually presented when in use. It is best to keep those two things consistent.


  • Infrastructure

    @dobey I mean the corners of the new App switcher window inside the screenshot. Not the screenshots...



  • @flohack Yes I know. Those are "screenshots" of the apps I think.



  • I'd also say the current design of the app switcher, showing slightly angled screenshots of the apps, makes it easier to distinguish the apps.



  • Still pretty messy. I'd like to see only 4 gestures:

    pull right = in app: application menu (replaces hamburger).
    push left = in app: back (replaces back arrow).
    push up = notifications. Opposite to everyone else, but its easier to access with thumb.
    pull down = multitasking (grid - BB10/N9 style), then do left/right cycle between multitasking, apps & feed (N9 style).

    With notifications you could have a BB10 style mini notification (icons + numbers) when partly transitioned. With this you can quickly 'peek' to see what kind of notification you have.

    The main thing is to replace the hamburger and back-arrow as they are often too small and/or in a thumb-inaccessible corner of the screen - immensely frustrating when trying to use the device with one hand while carrying the shopping, or holding a rail on the train.



  • @cpb I don't think that is feasible. The edge gestures are system gestures. In-app gestures are something the app can do if they want (but it can't be from the left/top/right edges, only the bottom.

    Changing to what you suggest would be untenable, requiring every app developer to change their apps, and a massive overhaul of the whole system.


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to UBports Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.